TL;DR
Whether affiliates are the right acquisition channel for your business depends on how your customers buy, who already influences them, whether the economics leave room for a competitive commission, and whether the business can support partners once the channel starts working.
Before you recruit anyone, I’d check seven things: whether people research or compare products like yours, whether third parties already influence those customers, whether there are realistic partners you could recruit, whether each customer is valuable enough to support a competitive commission, whether your site converts qualified traffic, whether an affiliate could make reasonable money from that traffic, and whether your business can support the channel if it starts working.
Sometimes my answer is no, and that is a useful answer. If most of those seven answers are yes, I’d be interested. If several are weak, I’d investigate those first.
Sometimes My Answer Is No
Business owners ask me, “We’re thinking about launching an affiliate program. Do you think affiliates would work for us?”
Sometimes my answer is no.
I’ve managed affiliate programs since 2005, and I’ve seen companies spend months recruiting partners when the channel was probably a poor fit from the beginning. So here is how I’d actually decide whether affiliates are a good acquisition channel for a business, based on what happens when real traffic and real money are involved.
Start With How Your Customer Buys
The first thing I’d look at is how your customer makes a buying decision. That tells me a huge amount.
Some businesses naturally fit affiliate marketing. Software is a good example. Before buying, people might read reviews, compare several products, search for alternatives, watch a YouTube video, or look through best-of articles. Every one of those moments gives a third party an opportunity to influence the purchase.
You see the same pattern in financial services, cybersecurity, travel, ecommerce, and plenty of other categories. Searches such as “best password manager,” “best accounting software,” “best VPN,” or “Product A versus Product B” are interesting because the customer is already moving toward a buying decision.
Affiliates Don’t Have to Create Demand From Scratch
One thing people sometimes miss is that the affiliate doesn’t always have to create demand from scratch. There just needs to be a point in the buying journey where somebody else can influence the decision. That’s what I’m looking for.
When Your Customers Are Local
Now imagine a very different business. Maybe you run a restaurant. Maybe you’ve got one dental clinic. Or perhaps almost all your customers live within a few miles of the business.
You could technically launch an affiliate program. But I’d probably ask whether local search, referrals, Google Maps, or paid search would produce a better return.
So one of the first things I want to understand is this: where does the customer actually make the decision, and who influences them before they buy?
Search Your Category and Your Competitors
Here’s one of the quickest checks I use. Search your category, then search your competitors. Try:
- “[Competitor] review”
- “[Competitor] alternatives”
- “[Competitor] versus”
- “Best [your product category]”
Now look at the results. If you see review sites, comparison publishers, YouTubers, newsletters, creators, consultants, or specialist blogs, that’s usually a useful signal. It tells you there are already people making money by helping customers choose products in your market. Those are exactly the kind of partners I’d want to investigate. I cover how to approach them in how to find affiliates for your program.
The Label Matters Less Than the Audience
Here’s the less obvious part. I’m not especially interested in whether they call themselves “affiliates.” What I care about is whether they already control attention in the market. They might describe themselves as a publisher, creator, consultant, reviewer, media buyer, or comparison site. The label matters far less than the audience they already reach.
Do the Economics Work?
This is where a lot of businesses get a nasty surprise. You might have the right audience, and there may be plenty of potential partners, but the economics still have to work.
Take an illustrative example. Say you sell something for $30, your gross profit is $8, and the customer only buys once. How much can you realistically afford to pay an affiliate? Maybe a couple of dollars. That may work in some markets. But think about what you’re asking the affiliate to do. They may need to write an article, produce a video, buy traffic, or give you valuable space on a comparison page. A $2 commission may not be enough to make that attractive.
A SaaS Business Has More Room
Now take a SaaS business. The software costs $100 a month and the average customer stays for two years. That customer could be worth thousands of dollars, so suddenly there’s much more room. The business might be able to pay $100, $200, $300, or even more to acquire that customer. That changes the conversation completely. I go further into the numbers in how much commission to pay affiliates.
Affiliates Choose Where to Spend Their Effort
This is one of the areas merchants underestimate most. Affiliates are constantly deciding where to allocate limited resources:
- An article can only feature so many products.
- An email can only promote so many offers.
- Paid traffic has to go somewhere.
- A comparison page has limited positions.
From their side, the question is very commercial: which opportunity is likely to produce the best return?
EPC: The Number Affiliates Care About
One of the most important numbers in affiliate marketing is EPC, earnings per click. Merchants often focus heavily on the headline commission rate. Experienced affiliates usually look much further than that.
Imagine your program pays $100 per sale and the site converts at 1%. That gives the affiliate roughly $1 in commission for every click they send. Now imagine a competitor pays only $60 per sale, but their site converts at 4%. That produces about $2.40 per click. Which one would you rather promote?
That’s how serious affiliates think about traffic. A generous commission can still produce a weak affiliate offer if the site doesn’t convert. And when affiliates test something that doesn’t make money, they rarely send you a detailed explanation. They move the traffic, and you normally notice afterwards. That’s one of those things you learn very quickly when you manage programs from the inside.
Can Your Business Support Affiliates?
Now let’s assume the economics look reasonable. The next thing I’d look at is the business itself:
- Does the site convert?
- Is the checkout reliable?
- Can you fulfill the orders?
- Is customer support ready?
- Can you pay commissions on time?
- When a partner has a problem, is somebody actually available to deal with it?
This matters because affiliates can scale very quickly. Paid media affiliates in particular may start putting serious money behind an offer once they find something that works. A large publisher can also send a lot of traffic very quickly.
Success Can Expose Weak Operations
That sounds great. But success can expose weak operations just as quickly as poor performance can.
- If your checkout breaks under load, customers disappear.
- If stock runs out, the affiliate loses money.
- If commissions don’t get paid when promised, trust disappears.
- If nobody answers when tracking breaks, the partners may move on.
From an affiliate’s point of view, reliability matters a lot. I cover what happens when approved affiliates go quiet in why affiliates join your program but never promote.
What Kind of Affiliate Fits?
There’s another thing that’s obvious once you’ve managed enough programs: the word “affiliate” covers completely different businesses. A YouTuber reviewing software might earn commission. So might a comparison site. A consultant could refer clients. A cashback platform could send existing shoppers. A paid search partner may buy traffic at scale. All of them can technically sit inside an affiliate program, but they behave very differently and add different types of value.
So when somebody asks me, “Would affiliate marketing work for us?” I want to know what kind of partners we’re really talking about.
- For B2B SaaS, consultants and review publishers may be interesting.
- With ecommerce, creators and content publishers often make more sense.
- Software can work well with comparison sites and performance media partners.
- For a complex enterprise product with a very long sales cycle, referral or channel partners may be a better fit.
The model needs to match the way the product is actually sold.
When I Get Cautious
There are a few situations where I start getting nervous.
- The channel is a rescue plan. A business tells me, “We really haven’t figured out customer acquisition yet, so we thought affiliates could do it.” I’d want to see some proof that the product already sells.
- Poor conversion. If qualified traffic already struggles to turn into customers, affiliates will feel that very quickly.
- Tight margins. A weak payout makes recruitment much harder unless the offer converts exceptionally well.
- Nobody owns the program. Somebody has to own it. There are applications to review, partners to recruit, tracking problems to solve, compliance issues to manage, and commercial conversations to have.
- No clear partners. If nobody can identify publishers, creators, consultants, media buyers, or other businesses that already reach the customer, I’d want to understand why.
Sometimes the opportunity is immature. Sometimes the partnership model needs to change. And sometimes affiliate marketing simply isn’t the best channel to prioritize.
The Seven-Question Test
If you’re trying to decide whether affiliates are worth pursuing, here’s how I’d look at it:
- Do people research or compare products like yours before buying?
- Can you identify third parties who already influence those customers?
- Are there realistic partners you could recruit?
- Is each customer valuable enough to support a competitive commission?
- Does your site already convert qualified traffic?
- Could an affiliate make reasonable money from that traffic?
- Can your business support the channel if it starts working?
If most of those answers are yes, I’d be interested. In some cases, very interested. If several are weak, I’d investigate those first.
Two Businesses, Two Answers
So let’s go back to the business owner at the beginning, who asks, “Would affiliates work for us?” Here are two hypothetical examples.
Imagine they sell a SaaS product. Customers actively research the category. Dozens of publishers already review competing products. The average customer is worth $2,000, the site converts well, and the business can comfortably afford a $250 CPA. Tracking works, and somebody is available to manage the channel. That gets my attention.
Now change the situation. They sell a low-margin service in one small town. Customers rarely research it online. Relevant publishers are almost impossible to find. The maximum affordable commission is $5, and nobody has time to run the program properly. In that situation, I’d probably recommend putting the effort somewhere else. And that’s completely fine.
One of the most useful things an experienced affiliate manager can tell you is when affiliate marketing probably isn’t the right answer.
So, Are Affiliates the Right Acquisition Channel for Your Business?
Start with how your customers buy. Then look at who influences those decisions. Work through the economics. Check the conversion rate. Think about what an affiliate could realistically earn. And make sure the business can support successful partners.
That’s how I’d look at the opportunity from inside the program, because affiliate marketing looks very different once you can see the traffic, the conversion rates, the EPCs, and the conversations happening with the partners themselves. If the answer looks like yes, the next question is whether the business is ready: is your business ready for an affiliate program?
Want Help Deciding Whether Affiliates Make Sense for Your Business?
If you’d like help figuring out whether affiliates make sense for your business, that’s something I do through Affiliate Manager Expert. I can look at the offer, the economics, the competitive landscape, and the types of partners you’d realistically be able to recruit.
Affiliate Manager Expert provides founder-led affiliate program management, audits, tracking reviews, compliance reviews, and program cleanup for SaaS, software, fintech, e-commerce, and digital product brands.
Book a free 30-minute program review.
New videos go up on the AffiliateManager.Expert YouTube channel.
Quote of The Week
“There is surely nothing quite so useless as doing with great efficiency what should not be done at all.” ― Peter Drucker, Harvard Business Review, May 1963
Leave a Reply
Want to join the discussion?Feel free to contribute!